I've been working on a slideshow script that uses CSS3 transitions, or jQuery's animate when they are unavailable. I've created a custom function to do the slide animations, which does so appropriately. Everything seemed to be working fine, but I've hit a major snag during testing.
For one reason or another, there is an large delay applying the jQuery CSS before and after the transition on large slideshows. For example, the slideshow in the link below is around 9900 pixels wide (container width, most of which is hidden). The container is maneuvered to display the appropriate slide, using CSS3 transition and transform properties. The delay occurs applying the CSS between lines 75 - 82 in the paste below. In particular, applying the 'transition' CSS causes the problem. Add the 'transition' CSS to the stylesheet (rather than applying it with JS), and delay disappears. This isn't really a solution however, because we only want to use CSS3 transitions on specific properties, that can vary (using 'all' in the stylesheet would transition some CSS that we don't want to animate, but change regularly).
Animation function:
http://pastebin.com/9wumQvrP
Slideshow Demo:
http://www.matthewruddy.com/demo/?p=2431
The real problem is with iOS, in which the slideshow (and even the browser sometimes) becomes completely un-usable. I can't pinpoint any errors, and have really exhausted my knowledge of debugging JS. I'm sure it is related to this section of the function after playing around a bit, and disabling CSS3 support within the plugin altogether removes the problem completely.
I'm completely stuck, and really appreciate any help anyone can give.
--- Edit ---
I've tried applying the CSS with native Javascript rather than jQuery's .css function. Same results, no better performance. Also worth noting that this isn't happening at all in Firefox, and seems to only be a problem with Webkit browsers.
Anyone with a solution, would happy to make a donation towards a few beers! I really cannot figure this out!
--- Second Edit ---
Ok, so been debugging and I can see that the slowdown is caused by the browser repaint cycle that is taking a very long time. Is there a better way to handle this that the way it is already doing? Positioning the element absolutely is a known way to reduce repaints, but that isn't really working because the slideshow is responsive. Absolutely positioning the slide images or the slides themselves causes it to collapse.
--- Third Edit ---
A day later, and I've made some progress. Adding 'transition: all 0s ease' to the elements stylesheet CSS has gotten rid of the repaint caused by adding the inline CSS transition property via the custom animation function mentioned in the original post. This causes a significant performance gain, especially when removing the inline CSS transition property when the transition itself has finished.
Good stuff! However, now there is still a slowdown when the inline CSS translate is being removed (that was used to create the hardware accelerated transition effect itself) after the transition, and the left positioning is being applied. When the two happen together, there is a slowdown.
Breaking them up into two separate tasks (the translate removed, then the left position added in a setTimeout with no time specified), again gets rid of the repaints = performance gain, and looks likes problem solved. But sometimes, the CSS transition property isn't get negated fast enough, and the translate removal gets animated. No good, and don't know where to look next to work around it.
I think the problem is you're loading HUGE images :)
They are too big for the container you have them in, so you scale them down, which is even more resource intensive.
Try resizing them.
First of all congrats for your debugging!
I have been working on the exact same stuff lately and found out that ios devices don't support a large number of images positionned in the same page. It causes crashes and the only solution I found was removing elements instead of just hiding them. The downside is that removing and appending elements causes lags so you have to do it cleverly, when your transitions are done. I thought the best way to go was keep 3 or 5 images in the DOM and replacing the rest with thumbnails of the images, resized to fit the original. When transitions are done, I'd just put the large images back into place...
Hope this helps you a bit on the ios problem at least...
After spending some time analysing your code TimeLine with Chrome Dev Tools, I believe there's some optimization you could do.
As far as I can tell, every single one of your 16 images gets fully repainted every time an animation is requested. This seems quite obvious to me, as there are 16 images in your example, and the Chrome Dev Tools reports 16 long "Paint" executions every time in hit "Next".
In my humble opinion, you should figure out a solution that considers only translating two images: the one you want to hide and the one you want to show. So, consider please, not moving the rest of the images and, instead, leaving them all side-by-side to the shown image.
One more thing, using scaled down images is probably making the paint cycles quite longer. Avoid them whenever you can.
Well, think I've managed to figure it out! Just so you know, original post links don't reflect the changes as I've done them on my localhost environment.
Absolutely positioning the slides container has fixed the problem that was occurring with repaint speeds after the transition had taken place (whilst applying CSS properties). Obviously taking them out of the DOM has done the trick, allowing painting to take place much more efficiently.
I originally didn't try this too much because I knew this would add a lot of work to the resizing functionality. I had originally intended to not resize at all in JS, and rely on percentages to do the dirty work. Absolutely positioning the container would cause the slideshow viewport to collapse, rendering the native resizing useless.
However, I was already having problems with sub-pixel rendering in other browsers anyway, so I guess it was time to bite the bullet and rely on fixed pixel values. I then used JS to handle the resizing, using the window resize event. All seems good, however the slideshow was still collapsed due to the positioning. Assigning height values wasn't working correctly, so was at a bit of a loss.
Thankfully, I came across a neat little trick of setting the 'padding-top' of the slideshow viewport to a percentage value, dynamically calculated (desired slideshow height, set in the settings panel for this script, divided by desired width). As padding-top percentages are relative to the width of the element, this did a great job of providing responsive height and correcting the viewport again (no longer looking collapsed).
Here is some info on using padding-top for responsive elements that maintain aspect ratio. Great little trick: http://f6design.com/projects/responsive-aspect-ratio/
All is good now, and things are working well in iOS and webkit browsers. Everything is extremely quick and working as it should. Four days later, and it is finally figured out. Not happy about having to resort to JS for resizing, but I guess it was always going to happen due to percentage inconsistencies between browsers. Lots of decimals = no good!
Thanks to all who tried to point me in the right direction. Definitely got me thinking, and learned a lot of debugging skills that I can use again to make sure transitions are performing well. Thanks again!
not sure if this helps or not but I noticed you use 3d translation - I would think a simple 2d translation would be enough especially since your third parameter is 0 and might accelerate the issue, also go with fewer images as Armel L. suggested, don't have an iphone to test though... alternatively, this is a solution I used before css3 but should still work move the element containing the images using javascript by modifying left (?and top - the demo only moves left and right though? without the transition effects) and this way you can fine-tune the refresh rate which I think might account for the slowdown... you can go as low as 18 fps without anyone noticing, might even be good enough with just 16fps
I had this when I was first designing a magazine carousel-style page device.
If you have a series of images within a long "tray", even if they are not within the viewport, they will still take up ram, and you can effectively have five or so before leaks and nastiness begin to happen.
What I found works is "hiding" them ... But make sure they take up the physical space necessary.
What I also found worked was that one could make the 'previous' current and 'next' image are visible and move the tray, 'unhiding' them as they reach those three positions.
In my own system, I skipped the 'tray' holding e images and only had them at -100% width, 100% width and the current one a 0.
I never had much luck with the typical long-tray carousel with large scale background images... Especially with css3 acceleration.
Related
I have a simple blog that i'm developing using create-react-app (using react-scripts#next to get CSS Modules support).
Repo
Demo
The problem i'm having is the CSS hover transitions are very laggy and slow. I previously implemented this interface using Node EJS templates and everything was snappy and fast.
I'm thinking the problem maybe has to do with the PostSummary component receiving new props and re-rendering constantly, but all the props appear to be static once they're loaded.
I checked the Chrome performance tab and it said the majority of the cycles were being used by paint time (and not load time).
Very confused, anything I can test to resolve the issue?
When you have animations that you know will fire, it's good practice to use the will-change rule, to help the browser be more efficient.
Adding the following rule improves performance in Chrome substantially:
will-change: transform, box-shadow, z-index;
Also, check out this article. It provides AWESOME tricks to help improve the performance and animations on your website.
https://medium.com/outsystems-experts/how-to-achieve-60-fps-animations-with-css3-db7b98610108
One thing I see is that on hover you're changing the z-index. That has a possibility of slowing things down, so just be mindful when using any of the positioning rules. The transform: translate rules are much more performant than top, left, right, bottom, z-index. Not sure if you can get around using z-index or not with your design, but it's good to keep it in mind anyways.
Animating large images will cause performance issues. The first image in your example is: width: 5264px; height: 3393px;. Optimize the images for web and they should load quicker and animate smoothly.
Consider animating text and pure HTML elements, but try to avoid animating large images.
When you resize an image by transitioning it has to render the image multiple times during the transition and is very "expensive".
My users and I are running into a rendering glitch in Chrome only (on both Windows and Mac) where an overlaid div that I'm using for on-hover tooltip-style "popouts"(see first image below) does not get rendered properly in certain cases (see second image below). In all other browsers I've tested, it works as expected.
Here's how the hover popouts are supposed to look (and what happens in Firefox, Safari, IE):
Here's what happens in Chrome:
You can see it in action on this site if you look at May 24 using a browser window width of ~ 1200px (significnatly wider or narrower windows do not seem to work). The glitch only affects the popouts in the bottom right of the menu that are popping left, e.g. those on May 24. Hovers using the same exact mechanism higher up in the page work just fine. Glitched popouts are invisible (except for part of the carat), but if you click on the link to lock the popout in place and then hold left click while moving your mouse around as if to "select text" in the area where the popout should be, it will then render partially. Also if I open dev tools and try to select the popout, it will render just fine at that point.
I've been looking at this all day and trying different work arounds with opacity, z-index, etc. and getting nowhere. Does this glitch ring any bells for anyone? Is there a way to force Chrome to render the div, once its been positioned and unhidden? I'm fine with any work-around or hack.
I use a custom (and fairly complicated) jquery plugin for popouts. If it would be helpful to see the non-minified javascript for the plugin, I can post or provide a link to that, but general guidance that leads me to a work around will be sufficient to be accepted as an answer.
Edit: My Browser Build: 26.0.1410.65
(Per my comments)
This does indeed seem to be a bug in Chrome, though without a smaller test case to reproduce it, it could be very hard to track down. You may want to report it to the Chrome team with as much information as possible.
In support of my "it's a bug" assertion:
The hidden/clipped elements become visible when they are selected.
The elements underneath the hidden/clipped elements are not clickable.
This indicates that z-index and height is correct.
It only happens under very specific circumstances; the rest of the items with the same style work fine. The same item may work fine at a slightly bigger/smaller screen width.
Applying a 3D transform fixes it.
The problem goes away when I apply a CSS transform such as scale3d or translate3d. I imagine this is because certain CSS properties cause the browser to switch to GPU acceleration.
In this case, switching to the fast path for rendering seems to alter the drawing sequence enough to fix the problem.
Super hacky but this fixes it for me:
$('.drop-link.food').on('hover',function() {
$('.tool-tip').css('overflow', 'hidden').height();
$('.tool-tip').css('overflow', 'auto');
});
Obviously this isn't a "good" solution, and even remaining hacky you could probably optimize it to only force the redraw on the tooltip it needs to, but hopefully it helps...
Another clue:
$('.drop-link').on('hover',function() {
$(this).siblings('.tool-tip').css('display','block');
});
This won't fix it right away, but it seems like if this is there, once you've hovered on something, it will work the next time you hover on it.
Not sure if this helps with your situation, but over the last couple of days I've started to notice that certain site elements on Facebook and Weight Watchers no longer show up. Specifically it seems to be affecting items that (I believe) to be controlled by or dependent on Javascript. When I call up these sites in Firefox and Safari they work as expected.
I'm currently fighting a very frustrating bug on Safari, and I'm not sure where else to turn.
It seems most elements (but not all, and I can't discern the differentiating factor) that will trigger a focus event will cause all elements on the page that are transitioned or animated to jump ~2px to the top and left. And this only occurs on the first focus event after the page loads.
It's a little annoying to see the bug, as it's in the logged-in portion of droplr.com, and I have been completely unable to distill down a simpler case on JSFiddle.
If you have/create an account and log-in, click on this edit icon for a drop:
You'll see that on the first focus of the page, things jitter. Here's the timeline when there's a single drop on the page and I trigger focus on an offending element:
With more drops, it's just more of the same, but it seems to max out around 40 paints. And the profiler doesn't suggest anything nefarious. Just a trip through jQuery internals.
If instead of laying elements out via a translate3d or matix3d, I simply use top and left, this bug goes away. After hours and hours of debugging this, I'm at a complete loss.
Hoping someone has seen something similar, could take a look, or could give me advice on debugging next steps.
Thanks so much!
Update: Dave Desandro suggested it was the 3d acceleration kicking in, so I tried it out with a translate instead, and sure enough, that did not cause the jitter. I have no idea why the hardware acceleration would be firing up with a focus event though, and only once.
I've tried setting a transformZ of 0 on page load to go ahead and ramp-up the hardware, but no luck there, either. Any more ideas are welcomed.
I've had this issue a while back and honestly I don't remember what exactly was the cause but here are some of the steps I followed:
Check that you don't have hide() and show() for the same element in the next line or vice versa.
Example:
el.show()
el.hide()
Change Custom fonts to "Arial"
For the elements you don't want focus events add this code at the bottom of your scripts:
noFocusElem.off('focus');
This will make sure to remove any focus handlers you might have added by mistake
Finally place your css before any scripts. It's a know fact that adding css rules after an inline style has been applied may cause jitter especially if you're using line-hieght property
Hope this helps :)
I've had this happen when using custom font kits. Could this be the issue? Some events cause custom fonts to re-draw, which can cause a ever so slight "jitter" in page display.
Sometimes, manually setting heights and widths on all the parent HTML elements can reduce the flicker.
I know this question was posted a while ago and this is a bit of a long shot but here goes:
Maybe as a starting point go back to chrome and look at the composite layering:
Hit this into the address bar:
about:flags
You will be able to enable composite borders from within there. The red borders generally indicate a rendering issue:
http://www.chromium.org/developers/design-documents/gpu-accelerated-compositing-in-chrome
What I have found from time to time is that although there are rendering issues in Chrome the browser copes pretty well with hiding them from me. In other webkit based browsers however the result can be more noticable (i.e. android).
I've also seen flickering occur when z-indexes are being used in conjunction with content that is being transformed.
Either way it would be great to know how you resolved this issue (if you did). Post an answer to your own question perhaps?
A way to avoid spending time fixing load time twitches; you could set the page to hidden then make elements visible with the load. If your page is slow to load, you may want to have a spinner default to visible, then have load hide it. Then you could come back to the issue when you have nothing better to do.
Just my 2c worth.
The first thing I would try:
First in chrome, whack in 'about:flags' (yes I know you're not using Chrome). Find the 'Composited render layer borders' and turn it on. Once this feature is switched on you'll get a rough idea of what is being rendered/hardware accelerated.
See: http://www.chromium.org/developers/design-documents/gpu-accelerated-compositing-in-chrome
and look for any rendering problems. These are normally caused by z-indexes. Play around with any z-indexes and hide/show certain elements until the rendering issues are resolved. Then work from there. translate-z hacks and opacity can also cause problems.
From experience I've found rendering problems in other webkit browsers can be diagnosed using chrome. Flickering is a common occurrence on the stock android browser.
Secondly: take a look at the focus event itself and try things like preventing the default behaviour. Seems like a long shot to me but give it a go.
I haven't tested this, so I will be very surprised if it works... but here's an idea:
$(document).ready(function() {
$(document).focus(function(e) {
e.preventDefault();
});
$(document).click(function() {
$(document).unbind();
});
});
I've been running into the same issue recently and found something that fixed it in my case.
Check for anything that's hidden offscreen like:
text-indent: -9999px;
left: -9999px;
Removing any instance of these from the 3d accelerated elements (including children) stopped the content jump on focus for me.
As much as I've searched for information about this all over the internet, I can't find anything about it, so I've come here for help.
What's been bugging me: That no matter which method I use -- a jQuery .animate, or a css3 transition, [my] animations don't appear to be perfectly smooth. I didn't understand why they appear this way at first, and it's so subtle I ended up having to do some video capping to prove it. But it's definitely there -- the animations are juttery. Sometimes a frame happens too fast, and sometimes too slow.
Flip it back and forth six or seven times, and you'll hopefully see what I'm talking about.
I can understand this with jQuery -- JS execution isn't perfect. A quick profiling shows that indeed, when using jQuery anim, some frames get triggered too soon and some frames are late. But with CSS3?
What do people do to solve this problem?
I am moving the container using the margin-left CSS property and .animate of jQuery and is pretty smooth. Use the arrow keys to use it (left and right)
The current version of that project its now full of images, text, iframes and is still smooth.
Set this JS before your code:
jQuery.fx.interval = 100;
I have the weirdest of problems.
I have a jQuery function that animates the result bars of a poll.
function displayResults() {
$(".q_answers1 div").each(function(){
var percentage = $(this).next().text();
$(this).css({width: "0%"}).animate({
width: percentage}, 'slow');
});
}
As you can see it is a simple animation that elongates a couple of divs. It works OK until I embed it on my main page. The problem seems to be that there is too much OTHER content that breaks the beauty of the smooth animation. I was thinking of me being lame in implementing the JavaScript, CSS etc. but after a couple of tests and reverse engineering I found out that THE MORE CONTENT (images, text, video) I HAVE ON THE PAGE, THE WORSE THE QUALITY OF THE ANIMATION IS. I can only guess what the reason is... I really like my animation :)! Appreciate the help!
This demo shows how it should look like. I get it to work like this when the page has less content on it. By bad quality I mean not smooth flow of the bars. The worst case is when the bars appear in their final width in an instant.Tested it on Mozilla and Chrome and IE7 - no difference.
Edit: It seems that without the actual examples your hands are tied so here is something to work on. Just look for the red border, pick one answer and click the button. The language is Bulgarian if you are wondering.
A desirable behavior here
I can live with that here
Starting to look weird here
I don't get this here
If all of them look the same to you then my computer is to blame and I don't have to worry about this particular problem anymore, which already took 2 much effort. Use Mozilla if possible.
Edit 2: I found this SO answer that answers some of my questions about the animate() function and how it works, but the problem remains unsolved, at least for my computer.
How much content are we talking here?
If the page is large enough, the browser engine may simply not have enough power to re-render the contents quickly enough to provide a smooth display.
The way jQuery does it's animation is that it periodically updates inline CSS attributes. If the elements you're changing style's of are floated or have other complex interactions with the other elements on the page then the animation wont be smooth.
In short, put less stuff on your page. You might also attempt some sort of iFrame solution or switch to using flash to display the results.
This is just a limitation of the system, unfortunately.