I want to create an array of async functions but I can't understand why it works with map but not with the for loop. Can someone explain the differences between for loop and map in this case?
async function sleep(ms) {
await new Promise((r) => setTimeout(r, ms));
}
async function logic(i) {
let time = i * 500;
await sleep(time);
console.log(`${i} finished after ${time}`);
return time;
}
function exampleConstructResultsViaMap(data) {
const tasks = data.map((date, i) => {
const task = async() => logic(i);
return task;
});
return tasks;
}
function exampleConstructResultsViaFor(data) {
const tasks = [];
let i = 0;
for (const date of data) {
const task = async() => logic(i);
tasks.push(task);
i++;
}
return tasks;
}
(async() => {
const data = ['a', 'b'];
const tasksMap = exampleConstructResultsViaMap(data);
const resultsMap = await Promise.all(tasksMap.map((p) => p()));
console.log(resultsMap); // [0, 500]
const tasksFor = exampleConstructResultsViaFor(data);
const resultsFor = await Promise.all(tasksFor.map((p) => p()));
console.log(resultsFor); // [1000, 1000]
})();
When you call logic(i) in exampleConstructResultsViaFor the loop has already finished, and i equals 2.
What you can do is use a simple for loop with let that's block scoped:
function exampleConstructResultsViaFor(data) {
const tasks = [];
for (let i = 0; i < data.length; i++) {
const task = async() => logic(i);
tasks.push(task);
}
return tasks;
}
Or create a closure:
const task = ((j) => async() => logic(j))(i);
Related
I am trying to execute allCountryData and return a promise its working fine but after allCountryData is done executing I want to perform a operation on that returned data / or allCountryDataArray and store the highest values in arrayOfHighestCases
Note I can't chain the other login in allCountryData.
Please help let me know if you need any more details
export const allCountryDataArray = [];
export const arrayOfHighestCases = [];
const allCountryData = async () => {
sendHTTP()
.then((res) => {
return res.response;
})
.then((res) => {
allCountryDataArray.push(...res);
return allCountryDataArray;
});
return await allCountryDataArray;
// Highest Cases
};
The code is below is not working
const highestCasesData = async () => {
// const allCountryDataArrayy = await allCountryData();
// allCountryData()
// .then((data) => {
// console.log(arrayOfHighestCases[0]);
// })
// .then((res) => {
const np = new Promise((res, rej) => {
res(allCountryData());
});
return np.then((res) => {
console.log(res);
const arrayofHigh = allCountryDataArray.sort((a, b) => {
if (a.cases.total < b.cases.total) {
return 1;
} else if (a.cases.total > b.cases.total) {
return -1;
} else {
return 0;
}
});
console.log(arrayofHigh);
const slicedArray = arrayofHigh.slice(0, 6);
for (const eachHighCase of slicedArray) {
arrayOfHighestCases.push(eachHighCase);
}
console.log(arrayOfHighestCases);
return arrayOfHighestCases;
});
// });
};
highestCasesData();
Filling global arrays with async data is a way into timing conflicts. Bugs where the data ain't there, except when you look it is there and yet another question here on my SO about "Why can't my code access data? When I check in the console everything looks fine, but my code ain't working."
If you want to store something, store Promises of these arrays or memoize the functions.
const allCountryData = async () => {
const res = await sendHTTP();
return res.response;
};
const highestCasesData = async () => {
const allCountryDataArray = await allCountryData();
return allCountryDataArray
.slice() // make a copy, don't mutate the original array
.sort((a, b) => b.cases.total - a.cases.total) // sort it by total cases DESC
.slice(0, 6); // take the first 6 items with the highest total cases
}
This is working please let me know if I can make some more improvements
const allCountryData = async () => {
return sendHTTP()
.then((res) => {
return res.response;
})
.then((res) => {
allCountryDataArray.push(...res);
return allCountryDataArray;
});
// Highest Cases
};
const highestCasesData = async () => {
return allCountryData().then((res) => {
console.log(res);
const arrayofHigh = allCountryDataArray.sort((a, b) => {
if (a.cases.total < b.cases.total) {
return 1;
} else if (a.cases.total > b.cases.total) {
return -1;
} else {
return 0;
}
});
console.log(arrayofHigh);
const slicedArray = arrayofHigh.slice(0, 6);
for (const eachHighCase of slicedArray) {
arrayOfHighestCases.push(eachHighCase);
}
console.log(arrayOfHighestCases);
return arrayOfHighestCases;
});
};
highestCasesData();
Inside an async function i have a loop and inside this loop i need to use await to resolve a promise from another async function.
async function smallestCities(states) {
const citiesInState = [];
for (const state of states) {
const length = await lengthOfState(state.Sigla);
const stateObject = {
state: state.Sigla,
cities: length,
};
citiesInState.push(stateObject);
}
citiesInState.sort((a, b) => {
if (a.cities > b.cities) return 1;
if (a.cities < b.cities) return -1;
return 0;
});
return citiesInState.filter((_, index) => index < 5).reverse();
}
It's work fine, but eslint says to disallow await inside of loops and use Promise.all() to resolve all promises.
The problem is that my promises are in an object property:
How can i figure out to use Promise.all() with properties of an object?
Chain a .then onto the lengthOfState call to make the whole Promise resolve to the object you need, inside the Promise.all:
const citiesInState = await Promise.all(
states.map(
state => lengthOfState(state.Sigla).then(cities => ({ state: state.Sigla, cities }))
)
);
const NEW_LAND = 'newLand'
const ACTUAL_FINLAND = 'actualFinland'
const PIRKKAS_LAND = 'pirkkasLand'
const STATE_CITY_MAP = {
[NEW_LAND]: ['HELSINKI', 'VANTAA', 'KORSO'],
[ACTUAL_FINLAND]: ['TURKU'],
[PIRKKAS_LAND]: ['WHITE RAPIDS', 'NOKIA'],
}
const mockGetCities = (stateName) => new Promise((res) => {
setTimeout(() => { res([stateName, STATE_CITY_MAP[stateName]]) }, 0)
})
const compareStatesByCityQty = (a, b) => {
if (a[1].length > b[1].length) return 1
if (a[1].length < b[1].length) return -1
return 0
}
const getSmallestStates = async (stateNames, cityQty) => {
const cities = await Promise.all(stateNames.map(mockGetCities))
return cities
.sort(compareStatesByCityQty)
.reverse()
.slice(0, cityQty)
}
;(async () => {
const stateNames = [NEW_LAND, ACTUAL_FINLAND, PIRKKAS_LAND]
const smallestStates = await getSmallestStates(stateNames, 2)
console.log(smallestStates)
})()
I have a scenario where I am calling an API that has pagination.
What I'd like to do is the following, 1 page at a time.
Call API Page 1
For each of the items in the response, call a Promise to get more data and store in an array
Send the array to an API
Repeat until all pages are complete
What I currently have is the following, however I think I am possibly complicating this too much, although unsure on how to proceed.
export const importData = async() {
const pSize = 15;
const response = await getItems(pSize, 1);
const noPage = Math.ceil(response.totalMerchandiseCount/pSize);
for (let i = 1; i < noPage; i++) {
const items = [];
const data = await getItems(pSize, i);
await async.each(data.merchandiseList, async(i, cb) => {
const imageURL = await getImageURL(i.id, i.type);
items.push({
id: i.id,
imageURL: imageURL,
});
cb();
}, async() => {
return await api.mockable('sync', items);
});
}
}
export const getImageURL = async(id, type) => {
let url = `https://example.com/${id}`;
return axios.get(url)
.then((response) => {
const $ = cheerio.load(response.data);
// do stuff to get imageUrl
return image;
})
.catch((e) => {
console.log(e);
return null;
})
};
The issue I have at the moment is that it seems to wait until all pages are complete before calling api.mockable. Items is also empty at this point.
Can anyone suggest a way to make this a bit neater and help me get it working?
If this is all meant to be serial, then you can just use a for-of loop:
export const importData = async() {
const pSize = 15;
const response = await getItems(pSize, 1);
const noPage = Math.ceil(response.totalMerchandiseCount/pSize);
for (let i = 1; i < noPage; i++) { // Are you sure this shouldn't be <=?
const items = [];
const data = await getItems(pSize, i);
for (const {id, type} of data.merchandiseList) {
const imageURL = await getImageURL(id, type);
items.push({id, imageURL});
}
await api.mockable('sync', items);
}
}
I also threw some destructuring and shorthand properties in there. :-)
If it's just the pages in serial but you can get the items in parallel, you can replace the for-of with map and Promise.all on the items:
export const importData = async() {
const pSize = 15;
const response = await getItems(pSize, 1);
const noPage = Math.ceil(response.totalMerchandiseCount/pSize);
for (let i = 1; i < noPage; i++) { // Are you sure this shouldn't be <=?
const data = await getItems(pSize, i);
const items = await Promise.all(data.merchandiseList.map(async ({id, type}) => {
const imageURL = await getImageURL(id, type);
return {id, imageURL};
}));
await api.mockable('sync', items);
}
}
That async function call to map can be slightly more efficient as a non-async function:
export const importData = async() {
const pSize = 15;
const response = await getItems(pSize, 1);
const noPage = Math.ceil(response.totalMerchandiseCount/pSize);
for (let i = 1; i < noPage; i++) {
const data = await getItems(pSize, i);
const items = await Promise.all(data.merchandiseList.map(({id, type}) =>
getImageURL(id, type).then(imageURL => ({id, imageURL}))
));
await api.mockable('sync', items);
}
}
I'm working on shopify integration.
We receive an array items then loop through them and add them a new model (func1) then I need to use that result from the first and add it to a schedule (func2).
I need this functions to run sequentially because I'm adding the results to a schedule and if I have two results for the same date and they don't yet exist in the database if the they run in parallel it creates 2 separate entries in the database instead of one entry with the two values.
The way I need to return is func1, func2, func1, func2....
But at the moment is returning func1, func1...func2, func2...
This is a simplified example of what I need to accomplish.
const func2 = () => {
return new Promise((resolve, reject) => {
setTimeout(() => {
return console.log('func2');
}, 3000);
});
};
const func1 = () => {
return new Promise((resolve, reject) => {
setTimeout(() => {
console.log('Func1');
func2();
}, 1000);
});
};
const array = [1, 2, 3, 4, 5];
const test = () => {
array.map(x => {
func1();
});
};
test();
If there is something that isn't clear please let me know.
Thanks
you can use async/await and for loop in order do create a synced like iteration. and use it again in your func1 in order to reslove
const func2 = () => {
return new Promise((resolve, reject) => {
setTimeout(() => {
console.log('func2');
resolve();
}, 3000);
});
};
const func1 = () => {
return new Promise( (resolve, reject) => {
setTimeout(async () => {
console.log('Func1');
await func2();
resolve();
}, 1000);
});
};
const array = [1, 2, 3, 4, 5];
const test = async () => {
for(let i=0;i<array.length;i++){
await func1();
}
};
test();
This is the perfect place to use the traverse function:
const traverse = (xs, f) => xs.reduce((promise, x) =>
promise.then(ys => f(x).then(y => Promise.resolve(ys.concat([y])))),
Promise.resolve([]));
const times2 = x => new Promise(resolve => setTimeout(() => {
console.log("times2", x);
resolve(2 * x);
}, 1000));
const minus1 = x => new Promise(resolve => setTimeout(() => {
console.log("minus1", x);
resolve(x - 1);
}, 1000));
const xs = [1,2,3,4,5];
const ys = traverse(xs, x => times2(x).then(minus1));
ys.then(console.log); // [1,3,5,7,9]
Hope that helps.
const func2 = async (modalValue) => {
let result = modalValue*5;
console.log(`Function2 result: ${result}`)
return result;
};
async function getModalValue(i){
// rest of your Code
return { modal: i*2}
}
const func1 = async (item) => {
let {modal} = await getModalValue(item);
console.log(`Function1 modal: ${modal}`)
await func2(modal);
};
const array = [1, 2, 3, 4, 5];
const test = async () => {
for(let i=0;i<array.length;i++){
await func1(array[i]);
}
};
test().then((resp)=> {console.log("Completed")})
.catch((err)=>{console.log("failure")})
As I run this code, I wished to add the array final to the firestore -> sendGrid collection but it's always empty, although when I print it, it actually has the values.
I believe this is because of the timing issue, I always get [] -> value is just evaluated now (warning) and when I expand it it has the value.
function test() {
let today = new Date();
let addedDate = new Date(today.addDays(7));
let final = [];
let counter = 0;
let adder = new Promise(function (resolve, reject) {
db.collection("email").get()
.then((querySnapshot) => {
console.log(querySnapshot);
if (querySnapshot.empty !== true) {
querySnapshot.forEach((data) => {
console.log(data.data());
console.log(data.id);
let db2 = db.collection("email").doc(data.id);
let foodArr = [];
if (data.data() !== null) {
console.log(addedDate);
if (addedDate >= userList[0].exxpiaryDate) {
console.log("True");
}
db2.collection("list").where("expiaryDate", "<", addedDate.getTime()).get()
.then((list) => {
if (list.empty !== true) {
list.forEach((food) => {
if (food !== null) {
let temp = {
name: food.data().name,
time: food.data().expiaryDate,
};
foodArr.push(temp);
console.log(foodArr);
}
})
}
if (foodArr.length !== 0) {
let emailArr = {
email: data.data().email,
food: foodArr
};
console.log(emailArr);
final[counter] = (emailArr);
counter++;
console.log(final[0]);
}
}).catch((err) => {
console.log(err);
});
}
});
}
console.log(final);
resolve(final);
}).catch((err) => {
console.log(err);
});
});
return adder;
}
async function add() {
let add = await test();
console.log(add);
db.collection("sendGrid").add({
response: add
}).then((item) => {
console.log(item);
}).catch((err) => {
console.log(err);
});
}
Some points: (google if unsure why)
- prefer const
- return early
- clean code (eg. from console.log:s)
- cache fn calls
- functional programming is neat, look up Array.(map, filter, reduce, ...)
- destructuring is neat
- use arr[arr.length] = x; or arr.push(x), no need to manage your own counter
- short-circuit is sometimes neat (condition && expression; instead of if (condition) expression;)
- is queryResult.empty a thing? If it's a normal array, use !arr.length
- define variables in the inner most possible scope it's used in
- if having a promise in an async, make sure to return it
- prefer arrow functions
I changed the code to follow those points:
const test = ()=> {
const today = new Date();
const addedDate = new Date(today.addDays(7));
return new Promise((resolve)=> {
const final = [];
const emailsQuery = db.collection("email")
// an async/promise/then that's inside another promise, but not returned/awaited
emailsQuery.get().then((querySnapshot) => {
querySnapshot
.map(data=> ({id: data.id, data: data.data()}))
.filter(o=> o.data)
.forEach(({id, data: {email}}) => {
const db2 = db.collection("email").doc(id);
const itemsQuery = db2.collection("list").where("expiaryDate", "<", addedDate.getTime())
// another one!
itemsQuery.get().then((items) => {
const food = items.filter(o=> o).map(o=> o.data()).filter(o=> o)
.forEach(({name, expiaryDate: time})=> ({name, time}))
food.length && final.push({email, food})
}).catch(console.error);
});
// resolving before the two async ones have finished!!
resolve(final);
}).catch(console.error);
});
}
const add = async ()=> {
let response = await test();
return db.collection("sendGrid").add({response})
.then((item) => console.log('item:', item))
.catch(console.error)
}
Now, we can see that there is an issue with the async flow ("timing issue" in your words). I'll add one more best practice:
- use async/await when possible
Changing using that one makes it more clear, and solves the issue:
const test = async ()=> {
const today = new Date();
const addedDate = new Date(today.addDays(7));
const emailsQuery = db.collection("email")
const querySnapshot = await emailsQuery.get()
const emailEntries = querySnapshot
.map(data=> ({id: data.id, data: data.data()}))
.filter(o=> o.data)
// invoking an async fn -> promise; map returns the result of all invoked fns -> array of promises
const promisedItems = emailEntries.map(async ({id, data: {email}}) => {
const db2 = db.collection("email").doc(id);
const itemsQuery = db2.collection("list").where("expiaryDate", "<", addedDate.getTime())
const items = await itemsQuery.get()
const food = items.filter(o=> o).map(o=> o.data()).filter(o=> o)
.forEach(({name, expiaryDate: time})=> ({name, time}))
return {email, food}
});
const items = await Promise.all(promisedItems)
return items.filter(item=> item.food.length)
}
const add = async ()=> {
let response = await test();
return db.collection("sendGrid").add({response})
.then((item) => console.log('item:', item))
.catch(console.error)
}
Now, the flow is clear!
.
Even more concise (though lack of var names -> less clear) - just for kicks:
// (spelled-fixed expiryDate); down to 23% loc, 42% char
const getUnexpiredFoodPerEmails = async ({expiryDateMax} = {
expiryDateMax: new Date(new Date().addDays(7)),
})=> (await Promise.all((await db.collection('email').get())
.map(data=> ({id: data.id, data: data.data()})).filter(o=> o.data)
.map(async ({id, data: {email}})=> ({
email,
food: (await db.collection('email').doc(id).collection('list')
.where('expiryDate', '<', expiryDateMax.getTime()).get())
.filter(o=> o).map(o=> o.data()).filter(o=> o)
.forEach(({name, expiryDate: time})=> ({name, time})),
}))
)).filter(item=> item.food.length)
const add = async ()=> db.collection('sendGrid').add({
response: await getUnexpiredFoodPerEmails(),
}).then(console.log).catch(console.error)
// ...or with names
const getUnexpiredFoodListForEmailId = async ({id, expiryDateMax} = {
expiryDateMax: new Date(new Date().addDays(7)),
})=> (await db.collection('email').doc(id).collection('list')
.where('expiryDate', '<', expiryDateMax.getTime()).get())
.filter(o=> o).map(o=> o.data()).filter(o=> o)
.forEach(({name, expiryDate})=> ({name, time: expiryDate}))
const getEmails = async ()=> (await db.collection('email').get())
.map(data=> ({id: data.id, data: data.data()})).filter(o=> o.data)
const getUnexpiredFoodPerEmails = async ({expiryDateMax} = {
})=> (await Promise.all((await getEmails()).map(async ({id, data})=> ({
email: data.email,
food: await getUnexpiredFoodListForEmailId({id, expiryDateMax}),
})))).filter(item=> item.food.length)
const add = async ()=> db.collection('sendGrid').add({
response: await getUnexpiredFoodPerEmails(),
}).then(console.log).catch(console.error)