javascript - access properties of this defined in outer function - javascript

I've experimented with closures and found unexpected behaviour. Can somebody explain why this code works this way, please?
function foo() {
this.a='hello';
return {
aaa:function() {
return a; // this suprises me, how can be here accessed 'a' ?
}
}
}
o=foo();
alert(o.aaa()); // prints 'hello' ! , I expected undefined
I don't understand, why I always use var that=this phrase, If it is possible to access function properties from inner functions directly.
jsfiddle https://jsfiddle.net/5co6f707/

It displays 'hello' because you're not in strict mode, so this is the global window object instead of undefined, and a becomes a global variable when you assign a value to this.a. Since a is a global variable it is accessible everywhere. You could just alert(a); at the very end of your script and it would also display 'hello': https://jsfiddle.net/5co6f707/1/.
It shouldn't work (and doesn't in strict mode) and it shouldn't be used. If you intend to use foo as a constructor then you should use the new keyword when you call it (which would break your code, but in a good way).

When this code is executed:
o=foo();
foo is executed in global context and so this line:
this.a='hello';
adds a property to the global object - window.
When you call your aaa function like this:
o.aaa()
the variable a is not defined within the function so it's looked up on up the scope chain and it's found on window:
function() {
return a; // found on window.a
}
and so window.a is returned.

Related

Why variables of function declared outside through "." accessible only through "." inside the function?

I initialized a variable of function through "." outside the function. Regarding closure rule, it should be set inside the function scope and after execution should be gone. But
Why after calling the function variable still exists?
Why can I access inside a function only through "."?
I initialized variable outside of the function through "." like f1.a = "any variable".
I checked if the variable of function initialized outside is accessible inside a function without ".":
I tried to get access to the variable inside the function. It seems if I get access to the variable by itself without "." it gives me an error "variable is not defined".
I checked if the variable of function initialized outside will be gone after function execution:
I call function and check if the value of the variable after execution is still available. Yes, it was still there.
f1.a = "any variable";
function f1(){
(function()
{
console.log(a);
}()) // a is not defined
}
f1();
console.log(f1.a); // after f1(), f1.a still exist
I expected variable "a" visible by itself inside the "f1" since I initialized inside the function scope f1.a = "any variable", but I can get access only with "."
I expected variable "a" will be gone after execution f1(), but it still exists
There are several things you need to understand to get a clear idea of what's happening here. First, JavaScript hoists function definitions to the top of the file.
Knowing that, you could imagine your code is something like this once JavaScript interprets it:
var f1 = function (){
(function()
{
console.log(a);
}()) // a is not defined
}
f1.a = "any variable"
f1();
console.log(f1.a);
Secondly, in your first console.log(a) you are referencing a variable a which was never declared. If you change that to console.log(f1.a) you'll see the value of f1.a as expected.
It's also not clear why you are using an immediately invoked function inside of your f1 function. It makes analyzing this code even more complex. It seems like you are trying to get a better understanding of how closures work? But for closures you should be interested in variables declared inside of f1, rather than properties of f1. For example, something like this.
f1 = function (){
var a = 'something'
return function()
{
console.log(a);
}
}
var closure = f1();
// f1 is finished running here.
closure(); // closure still has access to f1's variable.
I think the three areas you could learn more about to understand the code above are 1. Scope and especially hoisting 2. Objects, this and object properties and 3. Closures.

Global variable is not so global in Chrome

I'm learning JavaScript and going through this tutorial on jQuery's website.
In following example
// A function being attached to an object at runtime
var myName = "the global object";
var sayHello = function ()
{
console.log("Hi! My name is " + this.myName);
};
var myObject = {
myName: "Rebecca"
};
var secondObject = {
myName: "Colin"
};
myObject.sayHello = sayHello;
secondObject.sayHello = sayHello;
sayHello(); // "Hi! My name is the global object"
myObject.sayHello(); // "Hi! My name is Rebecca"
secondObject.sayHello(); // "Hi! My name is Colin"
I don't see expected output when sayHello() is invoked. Instead variable is undefined. But if I define global variable by assigning it to window.myName it works.
I'm using Chrome Version 25.0.1364.152 m.
Is tutorial incorrect or am I missing something ?
Full HTML is here: http://pastebin.com/4M27vDB4
UPDATE: Accepted answer explains what happened. I also want to mention possible solution - declaring global variable above without var. Because of following:
Furthermore, variables that are declared inside a function without the
var keyword are not local to the function — JavaScript will traverse
the scope chain all the way up to the window scope to find where the
variable was previously defined. If the variable wasn't previously
defined, it will be defined in the global scope, which can have
unexpected consequences.
You have put this code inside
$(document).ready(function ()
// ...
});
closure. In this case context inside it will not be window (it will be document object) and you will get undefined as you describe.
in your program you have used this.myName. this keyword is used to point current object. when you call only sayHello() then in that case "this" means "window" because default current object is window. Now you have not defined window.myName then it will give "undefined".

defining an undefined global variable inside a function

This is messy stuff (not my code but I'm stuck to it). A function depends on a globally defined variable.
function variableIssues(){
alert(someGlobalString); // alerts "foo"
}
Sometimes this globally defined variable is, undefined. In this case we want to cast it for further processing. The function is modified.
function variableIssues(){
alert(someGlobalString); // undefined
if (!someGlobalString){
var someGlobalString = "bar";
}
}
However, if this function is now called with a defined someGlobalString, because of javascript evaluation the variable is set to undefined and always get set to bar.
function variableIssues(){
alert(someGlobalString); // "should be foo, but javascript evaluates a
// variable declaration it becomes undefined"
if (!someGlobalString){
var someGlobalString = "bar";
}
}
I would like to get some suggestions on how to handle undefined global variable. Any ideas?
Global variables are properties of the window object, so you can access them explicitly with window:
if (!window.someGlobalString) {
// depending on possible values, you might want:
// if (typeof window.someGlobalString === 'undefined')
window.someGlobalString = "bar";
}
If you are using global variables, then this is better style, since it is clear what you are doing and assigning to undefined global variables wouldn't throw an error in strict mode.

change a custom binding handler so that it is assigned using an IIFE

I have a custom binding handler and want to modify it to IIFE. I have been reading on internet about IIFE but could not able how to change my custom handle into IIFE. So how can I change following binding handler into IIFE
define(['knockout', 'jquery'], function(ko, $) {
ko.bindingHandlers.er = {
init: function(el, va) {
console.log($(el).find('.n').text());
$(el).find('.edit').hide().end().find('.detail').show();
$(el).find('.ebtn').on('click', function() {
$(el).find('.edit, .detail').toggle();
});
$(el).find('.ubtn').on('click', function() {
$(el).find('.edit, .detail').toggle();
});
}
};
});
It's quite unclear what you're asking here :(.
Immediately-Invoked Function Expression (IIFE) is an anonymous function that executes immediately. In your case, if you can't be more specific, it's really hard to guess where do you want to place the iife.
I normally put my whole code into an iife in order to take advantage of the function scope and use it as a closure, thus minimising the global object pollution and it generally looks like this :
(function(global,undefined){
// the code goes here
// global === window
})(this);
In your case, you can do the same :
(function(global,undefined){
define(['knockout','jquery'],function(ko,$){
// ...
});
})(this);
Update :
Here are some explanations for those who need them.
The following pattern is used:
to prevent global variable leaks such as var foo = bar; (after which window.foo === foo)
to prevent the undefined value to get overwritten. Let's say you want to check if something is undefined. you have 2 ways to do it :
typeof foo === 'undefined'
foo === undefined
the second one is shorter but is often not preffered because one can simple overwrite the undefined variable's value : undefined = 13;.
By not proviiding an actual value for the undefined argument in the iife, you're actually resetting the undefined variable to undefined.
to generalize the global object
some say that the access to the global variable is faster than to the window object due to the fact that the js engine first looks into the lower scope
if you're running the code in a different environment than the browser and you have calls to the window object, your code might break because the global object is different from environment to ennvironment (adobe pdfs, node js, rhino ... ). This can be solved by remaping the global object to a variable (in our case global), by reffering it to the this object from the global scope

Still confused about JavaScript's 'this'

I've been reading through quite a few articles on the 'this' keyword when using JavaScript objects and I'm still somewhat confused. I'm quite happy writing object orientated Javascript and I get around the 'this' issue by referring the full object path but I don't like the fact I still find 'this' confusing.
I found a good answer here which helped me but I'm still not 100% sure. So, onto the example. The following script is linked from test.html with <script src="js/test.js"></script>
if (!nick) {
var nick = {};
}
nick.name= function(){
var helloA = 'Hello A';
console.log('1.',this, this.helloA);
var init = function(){
var helloB = 'Hello B';
console.log('2.',this, this.helloB);
}
return {
init: init
}
}();
nick.name.init();
What kind of expected to see was
1. Object {} nick.name, 'Hello A'
2. Object {} init, 'Hello B'
But what I get is this?
1. Window test.html, undefined
2. Object {} init, undefined
I think I understand some of what's happening there but I would mind if someone out there explains it to me.
Also, I'm not entirely sure why the first 'console.log' is being called at all? If I remove the call to the init function //nick.name.init() firebug still outputs 1. Window test.html, undefined. Why is that? Why does nick.name() get called by the window object when the html page loads?
Many thanks
Also, I'm not entirely sure why the first 'console.log' is being called at all?
nick.name = function(){
// ...
}();
Here you define a function, call it immediately (hence ()) and assign its return value ({init: init}) to nick.name
So the execution is:
Create a variable called nick if there isn't one with a non-falsey value already
Create an anonymous function that…
Creates a variable called helloA in its own scope
Outputs data using console.log containing "1" (as is), this (the window because the function is executing in the global context instead of as a method), and this.helloA (window.helloA, which doesn't exist.
Defines a function called init
Returns an object which gets assigned to nick.name
Then you call nick.name.init() which executes the init function in the context of name.
This defines helloB
Then it console.logs with "2" (as is), this (name), and this.helloB (nick.name.helloB - which doesn't exist)
So the first output you get is from console.log('1.',this, this.helloA);
I think your main problem is that you are confusing this.foo (properties on the object on which a method is being called) with variable scope (variables available to a function)
It's much simpler if you think about this as a function, not as a variable. Essentially, this is a function which returns current "execution context", that is, the object the current function was "applied" to. For example, consider the following
function t() { console.log(this)}
this will return very different results depending upon how you call it
t() // print window
bar = { func: t }
bar.func() // print bar
foo = { x: 123 }
t.apply(foo) // print foo
this is defined on a per-function basis when the function call is made. When you call a function as o.f(), this will be o within the function, and when you call it as f(), this will be the global object (for browsers, this is the window).
You wrote nick.name = function(){...}(); and the right-hand part is of the form f(), hence the Window.
var foo = bar; defines a local variable. It may not be accessed as this.foo (well, except when you're at global scope, but that's silly). To define a member, you usually write this.foo = bar; instead.
This is what your code does:
It creates an object and assigns to the variable nick.
It creates an anonymous function.
It calls the function (in the window scope).
It assigns the return value (an object containing the init property) to the name property of the object.
It gets the value from the init property, which is a method delegate, and calls the method.
The anonymous function does this:
It declares a local variable named helloA and assigns a string to it. (Creating a local variable doesn't add it as a property to the current object.)
It logs this (window) and the helloA property (which doesn't exist).
It creates an anonymous function and assignes to the local variable init.
It creates an object with the property init and the value from the local variable init.
The anonymous function assigned to the init property does this:
It declares a local variable named helloB and assigns a string to it. (Creating a local variable doesn't add it as a property to the current object.)
It logs this (the object from the name property, not the nick variable), and the helloB property (which doesn't exist).

Categories